Tashkent, Uzbekistan (UzDaily.uz) — Chinese President Xi Jinping, Russian President Vladimir Putin and US President Donald Trump held their first trilateral summit on 19 November, adopting a declaration pledging to reform the United Nations and hold talks on reducing nuclear risks. The announcement was reported by [source].
The document, titled “Declaration of the Heads of State of China, Russia and the United States on Moving Towards Peace”, also addresses stable energy supplies and the limits of international criminal jurisdiction.
How the meeting unfolded
The summit took place in Shenzhen, in the southern Chinese province of Guangdong, where China is hosting the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) conference. Chinese officials described the meeting as a summit of “groundbreaking significance”.
According to available reports, Putin proposed the format during a telephone conversation with Trump in October. The meeting was arranged to coincide with APEC. The trilateral talks lasted around 90 minutes. Before them, Trump held separate meetings with Putin and Xi.
Xi opened the talks by saying that peace between major countries brings stability, while conflicts between them lead to global chaos. Putin spoke about the contribution the three countries could make to international security. Trump described cooperation among the three states as a “special responsibility”.
What was discussed
The agenda focused on peace, strategic stability among major powers, nuclear weapons, energy security and the war in Ukraine. China's Foreign Ministry had said in advance that the leaders would exchange views on maintaining world peace.
According to available reports, Trump focused on reducing nuclear arsenals and preventing Iran from acquiring nuclear weapons. Putin reportedly promoted Russia's position on ending the war in Ukraine on terms favourable to Moscow. Xi favoured broader statements on peace and economic stability.
What the leaders said
Putin said Russia, China and the United States shared interests in resolving regional conflicts, including the Ukraine crisis, RIA Novosti reported.
“We stood at the origins of the creation of the United Nations. We bear the responsibility for preserving and strengthening the system of international law that took shape alongside the establishment of this universal organisation, including the UN Charter and the principles enshrined in it,” Putin said.
He proposed that Trump and Xi discuss global and regional relations, as well as energy and food security. Putin also pointed to the countries' shared interests in combating international terrorism.
“Our three states are united not only by their status as countries that emerged victorious in the Second World War, but, above all, by their shared responsibility for maintaining international peace and security,” the Russian president said.
Xi called on the three countries to defend peace together and do everything possible to prevent nuclear war.
“Nuclear weapons are a sword of Damocles hanging over humanity. They must be completely prohibited and destroyed,” the Chinese president said.
He said Moscow, Beijing and Washington should strengthen trade and economic cooperation and ensure the security of the global energy market. Positive engagement among major powers, Xi said, was not merely one option but a necessity.
“Humanity lives in a global village where everyone's fate is interconnected. We prosper or suffer together as a community with a shared future,” he said.
Xi urged the three countries to overcome the “Thucydides Trap” and proposed four principles for their relations. The first was respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity, while the second was rejection of confrontation. The third was mutually beneficial cooperation that combines each country's strengths. The fourth was regular contact and mechanisms to prevent crises.
Trump called on Russia, China and the United States to join forces to prevent the proliferation of nuclear weapons. He said the three countries bore a special responsibility for developments around the world.
“There are misunderstandings, and we often disagree with one another. That is understandable. But problems have never been solved by using old tools. We need to keep discussing them,” the US president said.
Trump said the United States was ready to engage in dialogue to secure a better future.
“Far too often, leaders in the past avoided talks with countries with which they had disagreements, but our approach is the opposite,” he said.
Trump also said efforts to reach a settlement in Ukraine were moving in the right direction and that both sides wanted the conflict to end.
What the declaration says
The declaration is brief and contains four numbered points. It was signed or approved at the level of heads of state by Xi, Putin and Trump. Unlike a treaty, the document does not appear to create legally binding obligations.
In the first point, China, Russia and the United States, as permanent members of the UN Security Council, pledge to reform the organisation. The stated aim is to enable the UN to respond more effectively to global challenges and fulfil its primary task of maintaining international peace and security.
The declaration does not specify which reforms are envisaged. It makes no mention of the Security Council's composition, veto powers, peacekeeping mandates, funding or the UN's relations with regional organisations.
The second point concerns energy. The three countries plan to increase the production and supply of petroleum products for the benefit of all states. They also reaffirm the importance of stable energy flows. The document sets no production targets, pricing arrangements, export commitments or environmental standards. Nor does it establish mechanisms for coordinating supplies during a crisis.
Under the third point, the principle of state consent and immunity for state officials are described as fundamental. The leaders also agreed that the International Criminal Court and similar bodies should not abuse their powers.
Supporters of this wording may argue that it protects sovereignty and prevents politically motivated prosecutions. Critics may counter that it could weaken accountability for war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide.
The fourth point reaffirms that there can be no winners in a nuclear war and that such a war must never be started. The three countries also agreed to hold dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and preventing the proliferation of nuclear weapons. The document contains no numerical limits on warheads or missiles, verification procedures or date for the start of negotiations.
What the document does not include
The declaration contains no ceasefire in Ukraine, peace plan, territorial arrangements, sanctions relief or timetable for negotiations. Although Ukraine was reportedly discussed extensively, the final document includes no specific joint commitments on the issue.
Nor does it establish a trilateral arms control treaty. Trump wanted to involve China in negotiations on reducing nuclear arsenals. Beijing had previously rejected such talks, arguing that its arsenal was much smaller than those of the United States and Russia.
The document also contains no detailed plan for UN reform, binding mechanism for energy supplies or agreed procedure for resolving disputes involving the International Criminal Court.
Criticism
Critics fear that a meeting between the three powers could resemble a “great powers” deal in which smaller countries have little influence. Some observers compared the summit with the 1945 Yalta Conference, although no comparable post-war settlement was reached in Shenzhen.
The United States, China and Russia continue to hold differing positions on Ukraine, Taiwan, technology, trade, sanctions, alliances and the future of the international order.
Russian presidential aide Yuri Ushakov said the atmosphere at the trilateral talks was good and that the parties had approached them constructively. However, he said it was difficult to say whether this format of meetings had a future.